• Home
    • About Us
    • Real Estate
    • Property Management
    • Podcast
    • Brand Collaborations
    • Music
    • Real Estate
    • Rentals
    • The Hamptons
  • Contact
Menu

Jenna and Joe

Street Address
East Hampton, NY 11937
631-353-1043

Your Custom Text Here

Jenna and Joe

  • Home
  • What We Do
    • About Us
    • Real Estate
    • Property Management
    • Podcast
    • Brand Collaborations
    • Music
  • Our Guide to the Hamptons
    • Real Estate
    • Rentals
    • The Hamptons
  • Contact

🦞 A Strawberry Lobster Cake to Kick Off Summer in the Hamptons

May 29, 2025 Jenna Van Asco

From the Coastal Kitchen: Beachside Whimsy Made Easy

Summer in the Hamptons isn’t just about what’s on your table—it’s about how it feels. The breeze off the water, the sandy feet, the sound of laughter over a chilled glass of rosé. And sometimes, it’s about the moment someone sees a lobster made out of strawberries on top of a shortcake and says, “Wait… is that a cake?”

This sweet little showstopper was born out of spontaneity and simplicity. We picked up a strawberry shortcake from Citarella—because why mess with perfection?—and gave it a seasonal twist with a DIY strawberry lobster crafted entirely from fresh fruit. No fondant. No piping bags. Just strawberries, a little imagination, and the kind of creativity that happens when you’re prepping for a beach picnic and want to bring something playful but still beautiful.

The claws, tail, and tiny strawberry legs came together faster than expected (Joe even figured out the eyes using raisins and birthday candles—dad genius). We brought the cake to the beach, placed it on a woven charger, and just like that, it became the centerpiece of the entire table.

Now that Memorial Day Weekend has officially launched the season, we’re already bookmarking this idea for future picnics, potlucks, and casual dinner parties. It’s proof that you don’t have to bake from scratch to bring the wow. Sometimes the magic is in the assembly—and the smile it puts on everyone’s face.

From our coastal kitchen to yours,

Jenna & Joe

IMG_0246.JPG IMG_8776.jpg IMG_0863.JPG IMG_8781.jpg IMG_8797.jpg IMG_8817.jpg IMG_8828.jpg IMG_8835.jpg

🦞 Strawberry Lobster Cake

A semi-homemade showstopper

Serves: 6–8 | Time: 10–15 mins

What You’ll Need:

• 1 strawberry shortcake (we used Citarella’s)

• 1 pint fresh strawberries

• 2 raisins or mini chocolate chips (for eyes)

• Optional: birthday candles or licorice strings (for antennae)

How to Make It:

1. Start with a shortcake base.

2. Use halved and sliced strawberries to form a lobster shape: claws, tail, legs, and body.

3. Add raisin or chocolate chip eyes. Use candles or licorice for antennae if you’re feeling festive.

4. Serve it beachside or backyard—it’s a conversation starter either way.

Tags hamptons
← First Timer’s Guide to Sag Harbor: Where to Eat, Sip, and Stroll in This Iconic Hamptons VillageFirst Timer’s Guide to Springs, East Hampton →