Not every spot that blows up on TikTok or Instagram is worth your time—or your money. But these three? They’ve earned their reputation… with a few ground rules. Here’s how to experience them like a local, skip the tourist traps, and actually enjoy what makes them special.
1. The Crows Nest – Montauk
Yes, it’s as dreamy as your feed makes it look—if you time it right.
Go on a weekday. Weekends are a madhouse.
Arrive when they open. Get your name on the list early and you’ll snag a table before the chaos.
Bring the kids. There’s a play set right on the lawn, and you can unwind while they burn off energy.
Beach bar magic. Sip one of their infamous (and yes, pricey) watermelon coolers while you wait.
✨ Don’t miss sunset. Lounge Chairs, fire pits, and that golden-hour glow—pure Montauk magic.
2. Round Swamp Farm – East Hampton, Bridgehampton & Montauk
It goes viral every summer for sky-high prices and that chicken salad. But if you stop there, you’re missing the best part.
✅ Prepared foods > produce. Skip the veggies. Go straight for their grab-and-go goods.
✅ The real standouts:
– Korean BBQ wings
– Whipped feta
– Guacamole salad
– Chicken tenders (yes, they’re good)
– Pies and seasonal salads
💡 Pro tip: It’s not cheap, but it’s fresh daily and perfect for an effortless beach picnic.
3. Duryea’s – Montauk
Duryea’s isn’t just a restaurant—it’s a whole scene.
Arriving by boat? Dock right at their private marina.
Waiting for a table? Grab oysters and a bottle of rosé from inside and enjoy the view.
Ordering wisely: Skip the overhyped lobster Cobb (at $100 it’s meant for 2–3 people). Instead, try the tuna crudo or the lobster bake—both standouts that feel worth the splurge.
✨ The view: Sweeping water, that perfect Montauk breeze, and a vibe that feels like vacation even if you’re just out for lunch.