Celebrate the magic of Christmas Eve in style with world-class dining at some of the Hamptons' finest restaurants. Whether you're a local, a holiday traveler, or simply someone looking to indulge in a luxurious meal, these top spots deliver festive menus, elegant interiors, and unforgettable dining experiences. Here's where to enjoy a truly special Christmas Eve dinner in the Hamptons this year.
1. Topping Rose House, Bridgehampton
Topping Rose House is synonymous with sophistication, and their Christmas Eve dinner is no exception. Set in a beautifully restored, historic mansion, this Michelin-starred restaurant offers a contemporary American menu crafted with locally sourced ingredients. Expect an evening filled with both warmth and exquisite flavor.
Must-Try Dishes: Crispy Duck Breast, Truffle Tagliatelle
Pro Tip: Pair your meal with one of their carefully curated wines for the perfect holiday touch.
2. Gurney’s Resorts, Montauk
For a cozy, refined Christmas Eve dinner with sweeping ocean views, head to Gurney’s Resorts in Montauk. Their restaurant promises a festive spin on classic dishes, offering an intimate yet opulent dining experience. Warm up with a signature cocktail and toast to the joys of the season by their roaring fireplace.
Highlight: Seasonal specials featuring fresh seafood and local ingredients
Bonus: Stay overnight and wake up to a serene Christmas morning by the ocean.
3. Il Buco al Mare, Amagansett
Celebrate Christmas Eve Italian-style with Il Buco al Mare's traditional Feast of the Seven Fishes dinner. Located in Amagansett, this Mediterranean-inspired spot is perfect for creating lasting holiday memories with loved ones. Expect a stunning seafood-focused menu featuring everything from octopus to lobster, meticulously prepared and bursting with flavor.
Special Offer: Their iconic Feast of the Seven Fishes is a one-night-only event – make sure to reserve your table early!
Atmosphere: Inviting, rustic-chic with candlelit charm.
4. Nick & Toni’s, East Hampton
Nick & Toni’s is a Hamptons institution, and their Christmas Eve dinner promises something for the whole family. Their festive menu showcases seasonal and locally sourced dishes, with a special kids’ menu that makes this spot perfect for a family night out. The festive decor and welcoming atmosphere will make your holiday dinner unforgettable.
Must-Try: Wood-Roasted Chicken, Sustainable Seafood Specials
Kid-Friendly: A dedicated children’s menu ensures even your little ones can enjoy a magical meal.
Tip: It’s a popular spot, so don’t skip on reservations!
5. The American Hotel, Sag Harbor
Step into history and elegance at The American Hotel in Sag Harbor. Renowned for its romantic ambiance and impeccable old-world charm, the hotel restaurant is the perfect setting for a sophisticated Christmas Eve dinner. Their à la carte menu pairs classic American cuisine with global influences, offering something for even the most discerning diners.
Highlight: Exceptional wine list featuring rare bottles
Perfect For: Couples looking for a quiet, romantic holiday escape.
Your Christmas Table Awaits
This Christmas Eve, treat yourself to the best of the Hamptons’ dining scene. With exclusive menus, festive settings, and culinary excellence, your holiday evening is sure to be unforgettable. These restaurants fill up quickly during the holiday season, so make your reservations today!
Happy Holidays and Bon Appétit! 🎄