Winter in the Hamptons has its own unique charm—quiet streets, a cozy atmosphere, and the lure of hearty meals by a roaring fire. If you think the culinary scene winds down after the summer crowds leave, think again! Plenty of incredible restaurants remain open during the off-season, serving up everything from casual bites to elevated dining experiences.
This guide takes you through some of the best winter dining spots the Hamptons has to offer. Whether you’re visiting for the weekend or lucky enough to live here year-round, these restaurants will make your winter outings truly special. Pro tip: Always double-check hours before heading out since many spots operate on reduced winter schedules or may even close for short breaks.
1. The 1770 House Tavern
For a classic Hamptons winter dining experience, the Tavern at The 1770 House is unmatched. Located in East Hampton, this cozy spot offers a more casual (but no less delicious) alternative to the main dining room upstairs.
Indulge in their expertly prepared Tavern Meatloaf or the decadent short rib sliders, all in a warm, intimate setting. It's the kind of place where the fireplace isn't just part of the decor—it’s part of the experience.
2. LDV at The Maidstone
Tucked inside the iconic Maidstone Hotel in East Hampton, LDV offers a cozy retreat for winter visitors. This restaurant combines Scandinavian-inspired aesthetics with a menu crafted around seasonal, locally-sourced ingredients.
Be sure to try one of their inventive cocktails, like a warm mulled cider, to take the chill off a winter’s day. The ambiance and proximity to art galleries make this an ideal spot for a cultured day out.
3. The Bell & Anchor
Located in Sag Harbor, The Bell & Anchor is a seafood lover’s dream and an excellent winter dining pick. The lobster shepherd's pie truly hits the spot when the temperatures dip.
With nautical vibes and a menu inspired by the ocean’s bounty, this cozy restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere where diners can unwind and enjoy a sophisticated meal.
4. Estia Eliatorio
For a laid-back yet flavorful experience, Estia Eliatorio in Bridgehampton is a must-visit. This Greek restaurant is known for its authentic Mediterranean flavors, offering dishes like fresh fish, grilled lamb chops, and classic meze such as tzatziki and spanakopita.
It's the perfect spot to enjoy bold, traditional Greek cuisine in a warm and welcoming atmosphere, making it a standout in the Hamptons dining scene.
5. Tutto Il Giorno
If you’re craving authentic Italian cuisine, look no further than Tutto Il Giorno’s Sag Harbor or Southampton location. This chic restaurant is known for its superb pasta dishes and vibrant atmosphere. In the winter, the fireplace is roaring and candles add to the vibe.
Pair their rich pappardelle with a glass of red wine for the ultimate cold-weather comfort meal. The modern yet inviting decor adds to its wintertime appeal.
6. East Hampton Grill
For incredible American classics with a luxurious twist, the East Hampton Grill is the perfect destination. Known for its infamous biscuits served with honey, this restaurant elevates every dish they serve.
Whether you're in the mood for a perfectly cooked prime rib or their standout Double Cheeseburger, expect attentive service and a welcoming vibe to keep you coming back.
7. Almond
Bridging the gap between upscale and approachable, Almond in Bridgehampton makes for a standout winter dinner spot. The atmosphere is warm and lively, with a menu that focuses on sustainability and farm-to-table practices.
Don't miss their signature roast chicken, paired with seasonal vegetables sourced from local farms. It’s a hearty meal that feels just right on a chilly night.
8. Lulu Kitchen & Bar
French-inspired but with a wood-fired twist, Lulu Kitchen & Bar in Sag Harbor is a perfect winter haven. Their open wood grill adds rich, smoky flavors to dishes like their lamb burger and roasted oysters.
Add to that their welcoming bar and stylish design, and you’ve got a dining spot that’s as much about great food as it is about ambiance.
9. Inlet Seafood
If you're willing to venture a bit further, the Montauk-based Inlet Seafood is an incredible choice for fresh, locally harvested seafood. Owned and operated by a collective of fishermen, it’s as authentic as it gets.
Try their sushi or daily catches—it doesn’t get fresher than this. Plus, the waterfront views give you an added bonus, even in winter.
10. Townline BBQ (Bar Area)
Love barbecue? Townline BBQ in Sagaponack is a must. While the dining room is always great, the bar area adds an extra layer of fun with its cozy fireplace and winter special cocktails.
Grab brisket platters or spicy wings and settle in with friends or family for a low-key evening that satisfies your comfort food cravings.
11. Highway
Highway in East Hampton is a top pick for elevated comfort food and international-inspired dishes. Their rotating menu keeps things interesting, offering everything from truffle pasta to fresh seafood dishes.
The sophisticated yet relaxed vibe makes this an excellent choice for both casual meetups and special occasions.
Warm Up Your Winter in the Hamptons
Winter may be quieter in the Hamptons, but it’s certainly not boring—especially when it comes to dining. From cozy taverns to waterfront seafood spots, there’s no shortage of fantastic restaurants to choose from, even in the off-season.
Plan your Hamptons trip, make your reservations, and get ready to discover all the unique flavors and settings that make winter here unforgettable. Grab your coat and scarf and enjoy exploring these local gems!