When summer hits the Hamptons, there’s one dish that locals and visitors alike crave: the lobster roll. Fresh, flavorful, and oh-so-satisfying, a great lobster roll is a rite of passage out East. Whether you love yours warm with butter or chilled with a hint of mayo, the Hamptons has no shortage of iconic spots serving up this classic coastal favorite.

Here’s our curated list of the top lobster rolls in the Hamptons—perfect for lunch after the beach, a laid-back dinner, or a midweek treat. We’ve tried them all so you don’t have to (but we highly recommend you do).

1. Bostwick’s (East Hampton)

A longtime local favorite, Bostwick’s offers a casual, welcoming vibe and some of the freshest seafood around. Their lobster roll is a fan favorite—simple, classic, and always satisfying. Pro tip: grab a picnic table and pair it with their famous clam chowder.

2. Marie Eiffel Market (Shelter Island)

Worth the ferry ride, this charming market on Shelter Island makes one of the best lobster rolls we’ve had. It’s all about quality here—minimal ingredients, maximum flavor, and unbeatable waterfront views.

3. The Clam Bar (Amagansett)

You can’t miss this roadside seafood shack along Montauk Highway. The Clam Bar delivers the quintessential Hamptons lobster roll experience—fresh, generously portioned, and perfect with a side of fries under a red umbrella on a sunny day.

4. Canal Cafe (Hampton Bays)

Located right on the marina, Canal Cafe is a hidden gem serving up lobster rolls that locals rave about. Expect a heaping portion of sweet lobster meat, lightly dressed, and served with a side of breezy dockside vibes.

5. The Dock (Montauk)

Tucked away near the harbor, The Dock is known for its salty personality and seriously good seafood. It’s no-frills, just fresh lobster on a bun with that classic Montauk charm.

6. Shinnecock Lobster Factory (Southampton)

A staple in Southampton, this spot is ideal if you like your lobster roll warm, buttery, and absolutely packed. Their rolls taste like they came straight off the boat—because they pretty much did.

7. LUNCH (The Lobster Roll Restaurant) (Amagansett)

It’s hard to talk lobster rolls without mentioning this iconic Hamptons landmark. Known far and wide as THE spot, LUNCH has been serving their signature roll since the ’60s. It’s a must-visit for first-timers and a nostalgic stop for seasoned regulars.

8. Hooked (Montauk)

A grab-and-go favorite, Hooked offers both traditional and hot buttered lobster rolls. It’s an easy, beach-ready option that doesn’t skimp on freshness or flavor. Perfect for those who want something quick without sacrificing quality.

9. The Gig Shack (Montauk)

Laid-back, lively, and full of character—The Gig Shack is a Montauk staple. Their lobster roll is packed with flavor and pairs perfectly with a round of cocktails and live music in the evening.

10. Duryea’s (Montauk)

If you’re looking for upscale ambiance, Duryea’s is it. Their lobster roll is elegantly simple, filled with tender claw and knuckle meat, and best enjoyed while watching the sunset over Fort Pond Bay. It’s a splurge—and absolutely worth it.

Final Thoughts

The Hamptons is home to some of the best lobster rolls on the East Coast, each with its own vibe, flavor, and loyal following. Whether you’re here for a weekend or the whole season, make it your mission to try a few (or all!) of these top spots.

Have a favorite we didn’t mention? Let us know—we’re always up for a taste test.

Follow along for more East End eats, hidden gems, and local favorites.