Looking for the best bakeries in the Hamptons? Whether you’re picking up pastries for a weekend brunch, indulging in a decadent dessert, or searching for the perfect Valentine’s Day treat, the East End has no shortage of amazing bakeries. From classic chocolate chip cookies to artisan breads and handcrafted donuts, here’s where to find the best baked goods in the Hamptons.
1. Tutto Caffé (East Hampton)
📍 55 Main St, East Hampton, NY
☕ Best For: Italian pastries, espresso, cozy café vibes
Tutto Caffé is a charming spot in the heart of East Hampton, perfect for starting your morning with a cappuccino and a flaky croissant. Known for their authentic Italian pastries and inviting atmosphere, this café is a must-visit for anyone who loves a European-style breakfast or afternoon treat.
2. Carissa’s Bakery (East Hampton)
📍 221 Pantigo Rd, East Hampton, NY & 68 Newtown Ln, East Hampton, NY
🥖 Best For: Artisan breads, gourmet pastries, seasonal specialties
Carissa’s Bakery is one of the most well-known bakeries in the Hamptons, famous for its beautifully crafted breads and high-quality ingredients. Their pickle bread is a local favorite, and their seasonal pastries always offer something fresh and exciting. Whether you’re in the mood for a sweet or savory treat, Carissa’s never disappoints.
3. Grindstone Coffee & Donuts (Sag Harbor)
📍 7A Main St, Sag Harbor, NY
🍩 Best For: Handmade donuts, specialty coffee
For the best donuts in the Hamptons, look no further than Grindstone in Sag Harbor. Made fresh daily, these donuts come in a variety of unique flavors like brown butter honey glaze, maple bacon, and cinnamon sugar. Pair one with their expertly brewed coffee for the ultimate morning pick-me-up.
4. Montauk Bake Shoppe (Montauk)
📍 29 The Plaza, Montauk, NY
🥐 Best For: Classic bakery treats, famous jelly croissants
A true Montauk institution, Montauk Bake Shoppe has been serving the community for decades. Their jelly croissants are legendary, but the bakery also offers a variety of cookies, muffins, and cakes. If you’re spending a weekend out east, this is the perfect stop for a quick breakfast or sweet treat.
5. Beach Bakery & Grand Café (Westhampton Beach)
📍 112 Main St, Westhampton Beach, NY
🍪 Best For: Chocolate croissants, custom cakes, classic bakery fare
Located on Main Street in Westhampton Beach, Beach Bakery has been a staple since 1988. Their chocolate croissants are among the best on Long Island, and their selection of cakes and pastries makes them a go-to for birthdays, weddings, and special events.
6. Tate’s Bake Shop (Southampton)
📍 43 North Sea Rd, Southampton, NY
🍪 Best For: Famous crispy chocolate chip cookies
No list of Hamptons bakeries is complete without Tate’s Bake Shop. Known worldwide for their thin and crispy chocolate chip cookies, Tate’s started as a small bakery in Southampton and has since become a household name. Beyond their famous cookies, they offer a range of fresh-baked goods, including brownies, scones, and pies.
Final Thoughts: The Sweetest Spots in the Hamptons
Whether you’re grabbing a treat for Valentine’s Day, a weekend brunch, or just because, these Hamptons bakeries offer some of the best pastries, cookies, and cakes on Long Island. From freshly baked croissants in Montauk to iconic cookies in Southampton, there’s something for every sweet tooth.
Did we miss your favorite Hamptons bakery? Drop us a comment and let us know where you love to go for the best baked goods!
📌 Looking for more Hamptons guides?
Check out our blog for more local recommendations, real estate updates, and insider tips on making the most of life in the Hamptons. And download our free guide to the Hamptons below!
