There’s nothing quite like a perfect slice of pizza—crispy crust, melty cheese, and just the right balance of sauce. Whether you’re spending a summer weekend in the Hamptons or you’re a local looking for your next go-to spot, there’s no shortage of excellent pizzerias. From classic institutions that have been around for decades to trendy newcomers with artisanal techniques, here’s a rundown of some of the best pizza spots in the Hamptons.
1. Sag Pizza (Sag Harbor)
A Sag Harbor favorite, Sag Pizza is known for its fresh ingredients, flavorful toppings, and wood-fired perfection. The vibe is cozy yet chic, making it a great spot to grab a bite before strolling through town. Their truffle pizza is a must-try, and they also have great gluten-free and dairy-free options for those with dietary restrictions.
2. Serafina (East Hampton)
If you love Serafina in NYC, you’ll be happy to know that their East Hampton location brings that same upscale Italian flair. Known for their thin-crust pizzas made with high-quality ingredients, this spot is perfect for a sit-down meal with a glass of wine. Their Margherita pizza is always a solid choice, but if you’re feeling adventurous, try one of their truffle-infused creations.
3. Alimentari (Montauk)
An Italian market and café, Alimentari serves up some of the best Neapolitan-style pizza in the Hamptons. Their wood-fired pies are simple yet packed with flavor, thanks to their fresh, imported ingredients. Whether you’re grabbing a slice to go or sitting down for a relaxed meal, this is a great spot for authentic Italian pizza lovers.
4. Sam’s (East Hampton)
For a classic Hamptons experience, Sam’s is a must. This family-owned institution has been serving East Hampton since 1947, making it one of the longest-running restaurants in the area. Their traditional, New York-style thin-crust pizza is consistently delicious, and the old-school atmosphere makes dining here feel like stepping back in time.
5. FINI Pizza (Amagansett)
A newer addition to the Hamptons pizza scene, FINI Pizza has quickly become a local favorite. Their signature sourdough crust is the star of the show—crispy on the outside, airy on the inside, and full of flavor. They use high-quality, locally sourced ingredients, making their pies some of the best in town. Pro tip: get there early before they sell out!
6. Pellegrino’s (Southampton/noyack)
If you’re looking for a solid, no-fuss slice, Pellegrino’s in Southampton is the place to go. It’s a casual, family-friendly spot with a great selection of traditional and specialty pizzas. Their white pizza and Grandma pie are particularly popular, and they also offer takeout and delivery for those cozy nights in.
7. American Pie (Bridgehampton)
Sometimes, you just need a classic, comforting slice of pizza, and American Pie delivers exactly that. This spot is perfect for a quick bite after the beach, with a variety of toppings and styles to choose from. It’s a great option for families and large groups, and their Sicilian pie is a must-try.
8. Francesca’s (Hampton Bays)
If you find yourself in Hampton Bays craving pizza, Francesca’s is a hidden gem that deserves a spot on your list. They specialize in fresh, homemade dough with flavorful toppings, and their cozy atmosphere makes it a great place to unwind after a long day by the ocean.
So, Who Wins the Title of Best Pizza in the Hamptons?
Honestly, it depends on what you’re in the mood for! If you’re after a classic, old-school slice, Sam’s or Pellegrino’s might be your best bet. If you want something a little more modern and artisanal, FINI Pizza or Alimentari will hit the spot. And if you’re looking for an upscale Italian pizza experience, Serafina is always a great choice.
No matter which spot you choose, one thing’s for sure—the Hamptons has some seriously good pizza. Did your favorite make the list? Let me know in the comments! 🍕 #HamptonsEats #PizzaLover