Best Restaurants on Shelter Island
Shelter Island might be small, but its food scene is mighty. These are the places I find myself coming back to again and again:
Vine Street Cafe
A beloved favorite for refined comfort food in a cozy, cottage-like setting. Seasonal, fresh, and consistently delicious.
SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill
A go-to for seafood and cocktails on the dock. Come by boat or drive over—either way, stay for the view.
Sunset Beach Restaurant
If you want a side of glamour with your rosé, this beachside spot delivers. Great for people-watching, French fare, and a fun afternoon.
Leon 1909
Chic and intimate with a European twist. The vibe is romantic, and the food never misses.
Marie Eiffel Market
A charming café and market where you can grab a great sandwich, coffee, or snacks for the beach.
The Terrace at The Pridwin
Come for dinner and stay for the sunset. The setting is elegant but relaxed—perfect for a golden-hour meal.
The Ram’s Head Inn
A timeless Shelter Island classic with Adirondack chairs, lawn games, and a menu that keeps it simple and satisfying.